The main difference between an erecting prism and a diagonal is that images appear vertically and horizontally correct for an erecting prism. In contrast, for a diagonal, they appear vertically upright but horizontally flipped. This difference is due to how light travels through each type of device. Erecting prisms reflect the light twice, while diagonals only reflect it once.
Astronomy is a fascinating hobby that allows you to explore the night sky and learn about the universe. If you’re new to astronomy, one of the first things you’ll need to do is choose a telescope.
When choosing a telescope, you may come across the terms “erecting prism” and “diagonal.” So, what’s the difference? And which one should you choose?
In this blog post, I’ll look at the differences between the erecting prism and the diagonal. I will also discuss the pros and cons of each type of telescope accessory so that you can make an informed decision about which is right for you.
Overview of the Erecting Prism
An erecting prism is a type of telescope accessory used to correct the image so that it appears right-side up. Erecting prisms are typically used in refractor telescopes, which use lenses to focus the light.
An erecting prism works by reflecting the light twice before it enters your eye. This means that the image will appear vertically and horizontally correct.
Advantages of Erecting Prisms
There are several advantages to using an erecting prism in your telescope.
Ease of Use
The first advantage is that they are easy to use. If you’re new to astronomy, an erecting prism will be a good choice.
You simply point the telescope at the object you want to view and look through the eyepiece. There is no need to upside down or flip the image like you would with a diagonal.
Improved Image Quality
Another advantage of erecting a prism is improving image quality. This is because it does not introduce any additional aberrations into the image.
This means you will get a clear, sharp view of the object you are observing.
Disadvantages of Erecting Prisms
Although there are some advantages to using an erecting prism, there are also some disadvantages.
Reduced Field of View
The main disadvantage of using an erecting prism is that it limits your field of view. This is because the prism takes up some of the light that would otherwise enter the telescope.
As a result, your field of view will be reduced by about 30%.
Chromatic Aberrations
Chromatic aberrations are another disadvantage of using an erecting prism. This is because the prism can cause different colors to focus at different points.
This results in a blurry, distorted image.
The prism’s age and quality will determine how many color errors it introduces, how obvious they are, and under what conditions. High-quality prisms minimize this issue to the point where, unless you have a trained eye and are actively looking for them, you might not even detect them.
Overview of the Diagonal
A diagonal is a type of telescope accessory used to direct the light path to enter the eyepiece at a 90-degree angle. This means that the image will appear vertically upright but horizontally flipped.
Diagonals are typically used in reflector telescopes, which use mirrors to focus the light.
The way a diagonal work is by reflecting the light once before it enters your eye. This means that the image will appear vertically upright but horizontally flipped.
Advantages of Diagonals
These diagonals come with several advantages.
Increased Field of View
The first advantage is that diagonals offer an increased field of view. This is because they do not take up any light that enters the telescope.
As a result, your field of view will be increased by about 40%.
Reduced Chromatic Aberrations
Another advantage of diagonals is that they can reduce chromatic aberrations. This is because the light is only reflected once before it enters your eye.
This means there is less chance for different colors to focus at different points.
Disadvantages of Diagonals
Although diagonals offer some advantages, there are also some disadvantages.
Difficulty of Use
The main disadvantage of diagonals is that they can be more difficult to use. This is because you have to look upside down or flip the image to see it correctly.
If you’re new to astronomy, an erecting prism will be a better choice.
Light Scattering
The coating that is used to produce reflective mirrors can also scatter light. This results in a loss of contrast and clarity in the image.
Erecting Prism vs Diagonal | What’s the Difference?
Read on as I discuss the differences between erecting prims and diagonals in detail below:
Inner Materials
The first difference between the two is the inner materials. An erecting prism is made of glass or plastic lenses.
These lens materials are easy to find and produce. On the other hand, a diagonal is made of a mirror. Mirrors are harder to produce than lenses, requiring special coatings to work properly.
Image Direction
The image direction is also different for each accessory. An erecting prism will reflect the light twice before it enters your eye.
This means that the image will be right-side up but left to right reversed. A diagonal, on the other hand, only reflects the light once.
This results in an image that is upside down and left to right reversed.
Light Scattering
The diagonal uses mirrors to reflect the light. The problem with mirrors is that they can scatter some of the light.
This results in a loss of contrast and clarity in the image. Erecting prisms do not have this problem because they use lenses instead of mirrors.
Chromatic Aberrations
Another difference between erecting prisms and diagonals is chromatic aberrations. Chromatic aberration is when different colors focus at different points.
This results in a blurry, distorted image.
The prism’s age and quality will determine how many color errors it introduces, how obvious they are, and under what conditions. High-quality prisms minimize this issue to the point where it is unlikely to be noticeable unless you use a very low-quality telescope.
Diagonals can also introduce chromatic aberrations. However, because the light is only reflected once, there is less chance for different colors to focus at different points.
This means that diagonals produce images with less chromatic aberration than erecting prisms.
Aberrations aside, the diagonal produces a mirror-reversed right side up, while the prism produces an erect but laterally reversed image.
Collimation
Collimation is the process of aligning the mirrors in a reflector telescope. This is important because misaligned mirrors can cause a loss of contrast and clarity in the image.
Erecting prisms do not need to be collimated because they do not use mirrors. On the other hand, Diagonals must be collimated every so often to ensure the mirrors are aligned correctly.
Price
Prisms are slightly more expensive to manufacture than diagonals. This is because they require different materials and more precise manufacturing tolerances.
However, the price difference between the two accessories is not significant.
Weight and Size
Erecting prisms are larger than diagonals because they need to contain lenses. Diagonals are smaller because they only need to contain a mirror.
This means that telescopes with erecting prisms are bigger and heavier than telescopes with diagonals.
Which Should You Choose?
The type of accessory you need depends on the type of telescope you have. If you have a refractor telescope, you will need an erecting prism.
If you have a reflector telescope, you will need a diagonal.
Erecting prisms are better for telescopes used in mobile applications such as bird watching or hiking. This is because they are lighter and smaller than diagonals.
Diagonals are better for telescopes used in stationary applications such as stargazing from your backyard. This is because they produce images with less chromatic aberration.
The light scatters less when you have a short focal length telescope or a “fast” telescope, as some refer to it in the industry. This indicates that using a mirror makes a lot of sense if its primary downside is minimized or nearly eliminated.
Prisms’ color problems caused by the angle of the light are minimized by the longer focal length and the design of some Cassegrain (“slow”) telescopes. Prisms are a better option for these devices when the problem at hand is removed.
It comes down to personal preference and what type of telescope you have. If unsure, ask a salesperson or an experienced astronomer for help.
They will be able to point you in the right direction.
Erecting Prism Vs Diagonal FAQs
What is the difference between an erecting prism and a diagonal?
The main difference between an erecting prism and a diagonal is that an erecting prism produces an image that is right side up but laterally reversed. In contrast, a diagonal produces a mirror-reversed image that is right side up.
What is a diagonal in a telescope?
A diagonal is a small triangular attachment that is used to reflect light from a telescope’s primary mirror into the eyepiece.
How do I collimate a diagonal?
To collimate a diagonal, you must align the mirrors in the telescope. This can be done by using a laser collimator or adjusting the screws on the back of the telescope.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between a prism and a diagonal for your telescope is a matter of personal preference. If you have a refractor telescope, you will need an erecting prism.
If you have a reflector telescope, you will need a diagonal. Consider the type of telescope you have and what you will be using it for before making your decision.
I hope this article has helped you understand the difference between these two telescope accessories.
Please be careful and use at your own risk
None of the authors, contributors, administrators, or anyone else connected with StarryNova, in any way whatsoever, can be responsible for your use of the information contained in or linked from these web pages.
